First American Financial Corporation (FAF) vs MGIC Investment Corporation (MTG)

First American Financial Corporation and MGIC Investment Corporation are both Insurance Specialty companies. First American Financial Corporation is the larger, with a market value of $6.7B against $5.9B — 1.1× the size. MGIC Investment Corporation trades at the lower P/E: 8.9× against 9.2×. First American Financial Corporation grew revenue faster over the last twelve months: 22.6% against −1.88%. MGIC Investment Corporation has the higher net margin (59.2% vs 9.33%) and the lower return on invested capital (10.6% vs 17.0%). Both pay a dividend; First American Financial Corporation yields more (3.59% vs 2.50%). Across the 23 metrics below, First American Financial Corporation leads on 13 and MGIC Investment Corporation on 10.